The tool needs to fit the task.  This is my mantra, but still — smitten with the novelty of the array of cool new tech tools before them —  the teacher candidates in my technology courses are frequently seduced into planning their lessons around these tools.  Thus “technology integration” can give rise to the same problems as ”activity-based” curriculum planning that is found in brick and mortar classrooms and to which Jay Wiggins and Grant McTighe offer an alternative in Understanding by Design.  My response to both groups of well-intentioned teachers is identical:  it may be a “fun” activity (or a cool tool), but what learning does it facilitate?

Integrating technology into face-to-face classes can help teachers better obtain their learning objectives by allowing them to extend and augment their instruction and students’ skills.  But learning objectives should not be altered just because (or any time) technology is added to the mix.  On the contrary: learning objectives should remain the same.

This is an important point for educational technologists to stress in their discussions with faculty learning to integrate ICTs into their courses.  But therein lies the problem:  as the Technology Integration Matrices developed by the University of South Florida and Northern Arizona University help us see, emergent ICT users are often so focused upon learning new technologies that asking them  simultaneously to think through the technology — or to analyze the types of thinking, activity, or interaction it promotes — is quite a tall order indeed.

This is one of the problems with courses like mine:  stand-alone “tech courses” reinforce this imbalanced perspective of technologies and the types of learning they promote.  Ideally, technology is best integrated across the curriculum.  However, the problem then becomes one of ensuring that course instructors across the content areas are well-versed enough in curriculum design and theories of technology integration to collectively absorb responsibility for presenting tech integration in this more integrated and balanced way.  Given where most of the contemporary generation of teaching faculty find themselves along the ICT learning curve, however, this is an imbalance we will need to live with for at least one generation, or until teaching faculty are savvy ICT users.

For the time being, then, learning how to integrate new media into one’s teaching — be  it in a stand-alone course or across the curriculum – should focus less upon the technologies in question than on the learning that they support and enable.  In teacher education or professional development situations where learners are also emergent ICT users, a constant tension must be maintained between learners’ dual learning trajectories:  between learning new tech tools and how precisely to integrate these tools into their curricula.  Carefully scaffolding emergent users’ thinking through technology may help teacher educators and deliverers of professional development maintain this tension.  The flow chart for evaluating classroom technology tools presented by Lisa Dawley in  The Tools for Successful Online Teaching (2007) provides a useful framework for scaffolding emergent ICT user’s users’ understanding of how to integrate technology into their curricula:

Copied with permission from the author (p.9)

Oddly, in fully online courses, the task seems somehow simpler.  What are the learning goals of the face-to-face classroom and how can I best facilitate them in an online environment? the K-16 online course designer asks herself.  Even though such courses frequently end up quite different from their brick and mortar counterparts — largely due to ICT’s affordances for more creatively or engagingly achieving those same pedagogical goals — one significant factor in this apparent difference may be that faculty designing online courses usually have a passing familiarity with ICTs.

This difference between the affordances of traditional classrooms and virtual ones is clearly demonstrated if one considers the way that ICTs can help support small group processes and learning in physical and virtual classes alike.  Group members can discuss, share resources, distribute labor, manage their projects, and more — all from anywhere in the world, at any time of the day or night.  This presentation on “Web 2.0 for Coordinating Small Groups” emphasizes both the plusses and minuses of using free and widely available collaborative software to coordinate small groups in virtual or hybrid learning environments.  Please view the presentation and comment or add, if you like!


Category: Uncategorized

About the Author


13 Responses to Tech for tech’s sake (NOT): Teaching emergent ICT users to integrate technology into their curricula

  1. hollister oberhausen says:

    Mieke D.

  2. [...] for tech’s sake (NOT): Teaching emergent ICT users to integrate technology into their curricula http://www.readwriteworld.org/?p=465 by Cynthia further supported  this ideas and remind me to think about an essential question during [...]

  3. [...] of ICTs integration into teaching and learning is to facilitate the learning as emphasized in Cynthia’s blog post which asked us to consider “What learning does it (ICTs) facililate?” throughout our [...]

  4. dhufupifq says:

    [url=http://jadethome.com/fakeraybansunglasses.asp]Ray Ban Clearance[/url] ,Defend clothing color will have to protect themselves, sometimes terrible events, because the situation is a lot like sunglasses: unique. Oakley sunglasses for the Asian sports and special living area can be seen as timeless and stunning sunglasses. The myopia choose sunglasses need to consider the problem of the lenses. Choose glasses plus a double frame wear layer of sunglasses, its benefits are simple, the disadvantage is the weight of the lens. Sports equipment sunglasses, polished and ultra-chic Oakley excellent choice for a new style shift was quickly added to the collection. Oakley sunglasses to protect your vision, by the sun. Equally important is that you know the shadow of it, your eyes can be duly protected. Oakley sunglasses, Oakley’s most famous product, the Oakley brand creative, stylish and comfortable design ideas.
    [url=http://www.unv.org.ph/documents/cheapoakleydispatchII.php]Discount Oakley Dispatch II[/url] ,No matter what, as long as seriously after years of experience in the design, production and market demand will be the public favorite. Polarized lenses can effectively filter out reflected light and harmful UV rays, and shatterproof, wear and other functions, is the most popular sunglasses. Fashion sport sunglasses PLUTONITE lens manufacturing materials, polarized Oakley sunglasses block 100% of harmful UV blue light, vision than the United States defined in ANSI industrial standards. Nose short selection of lenses the framework connector at the top of the sunglasses, otherwise you should choose sunglasses connector at the bottom, which can effectively “shorten” the length of the nose. In fact, pink lenses and lens almost uncolored, and no better than the general protective effect of the lens. 65% of women wear pink lens sunglasses, high degree of confidence than usual into the half. A good quality sunglasses can not only filter out more than 96% of the sun’s ultraviolet rays can be projected from the light weakened. Wearing poor quality sunglasses reduce visible light entering the eye, the pupil will naturally turn up, resulting in a narrow anterior chamber angle, resulting in poor drainage of aqueous humor, a long time, easy to induce acute attack of angle-closure glaucoma. If you have the habit of wearing contact lenses, you can be the same with most people direct purchase no prescription sunglasses, If you do not wear contact lenses habits, you have to be individually configured with prescription lenses.
    [url=http://fakeoakleys.mall-us.net/]Fake Oakleys[/url] ,The combination of Oakley shade selection is very large, including all the different beautifully designed. Oakley’s main goal is to make them completely satisfied with the prospects of several types of range of possibilities. The Oakley by strict distortion test, to ensure that the frame of the toughness and stability, mirror arm radian particularly attentive to the skin, weak arm end design, should face contour adjust. Heat summer, people often wear sunglasses to reduce the strong sunlight on the eyes. Selection and wear eye protection sunglasses reasonable and unreasonable is not conducive to human health. The delicate fine edges and circular framework is most suitable for a poetic temperament elegant family wear it immediately reminiscent of Hsu Chih-mo literati; heavy frame suitable for solemn family, wear it people think you can trust. You should choose your personality and preferences, as well as your requirements, according to the color of the lens. It is very important for you to choose. Can not deny that you come in front of us, I will provide you with the best service, so that everyone here with us to find the most real and most beautiful.

  5. mlhxvrjt says:

    The riders remain with the Musical Ride for three years, ensuring a constant rotation of officers. What I did was choose a wall. [url=http://ourhometeamusa.com]thomas sabo jewellry[/url] The entire Beach area is now called the Resort area cause the city here has totally geared that strip for nothing but tourists, you should see it in the winter months, not just during tourist season :) Its cold wet windy and empty, all those shops and fun places close, the restaurants (bars) are still open, but their business either suffers or the locals that couldn’t go there during tourist season go there to eat, believe it or not The Raven is still there and I think the Jewish Mother is still at the North End. Interest rates are at historic levels (last week the Bank of England restored the lowest rates since 1955), meaning that companies can finance acquisitions at a relatively low cost.
    [url=http://www.tucksteam.com]buy windows 7 product key[/url] I have a recycling bin at home: one for bottles, one for glass, and one for paper. Puno svega je nastalo, ali za početak nešto na što sam jako ponosna.
    [url=http://synaura.com]louis vuitton uk outlet[/url] Bulgaria is definitely special in every fashion plus same could be stated in relation to Bulgaria real estate likewise. [url=http://chiclayoenred.com]http://chiclayoenred.com[/url]
    There are more benefits of pig leather shoes from the point of comfortable and healthy view.. It could be presentations, secular parties, presentations, or occasions of any types where people meet and celebrate.
    [url=http://www.areaworx.com]chrome hearts 2013[/url] While you may not be able to pay a lot at first, just taking the initiative to get your debts current looks good on your credit report..

  6. lhgcswVQ says:

    polycopierions [url=http://www.breezeproducts.com/retail/?lvmonogram#93282]www.breezeproducts.com/retail/?lvmonogram – louis vuitton monogram canvas[/url] creusant pavoiserez dйsobйissais exclurent carriйriste rйtablissements commande finissez draperais insйrez basketteurs remorquйs marquйs touchantes conquises

  7. Zootfituppy says:

    Hermes Belts Replica | Purple Handbags
    Gucci handbags come in all sizes, colors, and styles. Jackie [b]hermes belts replica[/b] Onassis, Audrey Hepburn, and Grace Kelly are some of the famous women [url=http://www.jonescountygis.com/controls/hermesoutletonline.html]hermes wallets[/url] that carried a Gucci handbag. Gucci’s [url=http://www.martincountygis.com/controls/hermesbirkinbags.html#mXAzg]birkin bag hermes[/url] most popular handbag is pink with a bamboo strap made of leather and silk. In the [url=http://www.jonescountygis.com/controls/hermeshbelts.html]hermes belts replica[/url] 1900′s Mario Prada started the company and [url=http://hermesoutletsale.centerblog.net#ChqeO]hermes online[/url] made simple but elegant handbags for almost 70 years. Miuccia had an eye for fashion.

    Women just can’t have enough handbags. When she picks out [url=http://hermeshbelts.over-blog.com]hermes belts[/url] that perfect bag she makes sure its not too big, but big enough to hold her wallet, cellphone, some lipstick, and anything else she might need when she is out and about for the day. Now today most women have one of these sparkling bags as part of their accessories.

    Women love their accessories, and we can always find that pair of shoes to go with that fabulous new handbag. If the rest of your wardrobe is fairly sedate and you have a black coat or a denim jacket, you might be able to get away with one of the more eye-catching purple handbags that are out now. There’s no shame

  8. ezanczvl says:

    [url=http://www.winker.fr/parajumpers-homme/parajumpers-ugo-homme]Parajumpers UGO Homme[/url] progress, albeit slowly, and not throughout the entire city . You can explore promising new technologies, compare energy supply and alternative energy options, and learn about innovative and cost-conscious project implementation strategies. [url=http://www.optikerandresen.no/canada-goose-constable-parka-c-23_34/]Canada Goose Constable Parka[/url] Yihmyu [url=http://www.venmedlivet.dk/moncler-quincy-c-19_27_133/]Moncler Quincy[/url]
    [url=http://www.kentfenwick.ca/2013/11/shop-canada-goose-usa/]shop canada goose usa[/url] Pztdip Possibly the simplest way to get top quality as well as conventional Louis Vuitton Traditional Tote ought to be to obtain on the internet looking for these people. [url=http://www.browncow.ca/css/index.asp]canada goose outlet[/url]
    [url=http://www.byggmesterdalen.no/parajumpers-new-alaska-jakke-c-12_20/]Parajumpers New Alaska Jakke[/url] 7630455314

  9. nike free run 4.0 says:

    “little ghosts throughout Musha it, you in the end is who sent it?” nike free run 4.0

  10. outletvpgat says:

    [url=http://www.2014cheapboots.net/]ugg outlet online[/url] yv+.H [url=http://www.manilowsuites.com/menu.asp]uggs cyber monday[/url] ]>EdY cheap ugg boots LfuU8 [url=http://www.cheapsnow-boots.com/]cheap ugg boots[/url] v\vf] cheap ugg boots UVC/d

  11. Auto Protection says:

    We moist the whole car and clean it with a brush. Taking your
    holiday this year ought to be a time of satisfaction.
    Automobiles’ values also differ from dealership to dealership.
    You may not need it if all of the pipes are cooperative.

    my homepage … Auto Protection

  12. Milford Dilly says:

    I must tell you that it’s hard to find your posts in google, i found this one on 19 spot,
    you should build some quality backlinks in order to rank your page,
    i know how to help you, just search in google – k2 seo tips

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>



Topics I cover



Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


diigo education pioneer